CIS deduction on materials and labour: what comes off what
The 20% deduction is not 20% of your invoice. Here is what it is calculated on, a worked example with materials, and how to spot a statement that does not add up.
Most subcontractors learn the CIS rules from the gap between what they invoiced and what arrived in the bank. That gap is usually larger than it should be, and the reason is almost always the same: the deduction is not a percentage of the invoice.
What the deduction is actually calculated on
CIS deductions apply to the labour element of the payment. Materials are excluded. So is VAT, and so is the CITB levy where it appears as a separate item on the invoice.
The rate depends on how you are registered:
- 20% — you are registered for CIS and the contractor has verified you
- 30% — you are not registered, or the contractor could not verify you
- 0% — you hold gross payment status
That last one is not a formality. Gross payment status has conditions on turnover, business bank account and compliance history, and losing it costs 20% of every payment until it is restored. If a contractor tells you that you “should be on gross”, treat it as a question for your accountant rather than a fact about your business.
A worked example
An invoice for a bathroom refit:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Labour | £720.00 |
| Materials | £480.00 |
| Invoice total | £1,200.00 |
At 20%, the deduction is 20% of £720 — £144.00, not £240. You are paid £1,056.00.
On a job where materials are a small fraction of the price, the difference between 20% of the invoice and 20% of the labour is trivial. On a refurbishment where materials are half the value, it is the difference between being paid correctly and being paid £100 short every month — which is exactly the kind of error that never gets noticed, because the number that lands in your account is still plausible.
Checking the statement
The contractor has to give you a written statement showing the amount paid, the cost of materials and the deduction, within 14 days of the end of the tax month. It is a requirement, not a courtesy, and you are entitled to ask for it.
Three checks catch nearly every error:
- Is the materials figure the one you invoiced? A statement that shows £0 materials on an invoice with a materials line is the most common failure, and it inflates the deduction.
- Is the rate 20%? If you are registered and verified, a 30% line is a verification problem — usually the contractor never checked, and you are carrying the cost of that.
- Does the arithmetic agree? Deduction ÷ 0.20 should equal labour. If the statement says £150 was deducted and the labour was £720, £6 has gone missing somewhere. Six pounds a month is £72 a year, and it is your £72.
What to do when the numbers do not agree
Correct it in writing, in the month it happens, and keep the reply. CIS errors accumulate silently: each month’s statement is a separate record, and reconstructing a year of them in April from memory is how refunds get lost.
Keep every statement, every invoice and a running total of deductions. The total is the number that matters at the end of the year, because that is what you claim back — see the year-end calculation for how that works out in practice.
Two things worth knowing
A deduction is not a tax. It is a payment on account, held by HMRC against the tax you will eventually owe. If your deductions exceed your actual liability — which happens to most subcontractors with real expenses — the difference comes back.
The rates and thresholds change. The figures above are the ones in force when this was written; check the current rates on GOV.UK before relying on them for a return. This page is general information, not tax advice.
The CIS deduction calculator works out a single payment in the browser, including what being unverified costs you on that job. The pack below is three workbooks that do this arithmetic per payment — deduction tracker, statement checker and a refund estimator. If you already keep the statements and just want the year-end number, the calculator alone will do it.
General information only, not tax or financial advice. Every guide links to the current GOV.UK page for the rules it applies.