CIS refund claim: worked through from start to finish
Why subcontractors overpay tax all year and get it back in April — one complete calculation with real figures, and what records you need to make it come out right.
A subcontractor deducted at 20% all year, whose real tax bill is lower than the total deducted, is owed the difference. That is not a loophole or a trick — it is how the scheme is designed, and it is why the refund is usually the largest single payment a subcontractor receives all year.
The confusion comes from the two different sums being calculated in two different ways.
Deductions are on labour, tax is on profit
The contractor deducts 20% of the labour you invoice, every month, regardless of what you spend to earn it.
Your actual liability is income tax and Class 4 National Insurance on your profit — turnover minus allowable expenses. Materials, fuel, tools, insurance, the accountant: all of it reduces the profit the tax is calculated on, and none of it reduces the deductions that were taken at source.
That gap is the refund. The bigger your expenses, the bigger the gap.
A full year, with figures
Take a subcontractor with:
| Turnover | £45,000 |
| CIS deductions taken at source | £9,000 |
| Allowable expenses | £8,000 |
| Profit | £37,000 |
Income tax on £37,000, after the personal allowance of £12,570: £24,430 taxed at 20% is £4,886.00.
Class 4 National Insurance at 6% on the same £24,430 is £1,465.80.
Total liability: £6,351.80.
Deducted at source: £9,000.00. Liability: £6,351.80. Refund: £2,648.20.
Three things in that arithmetic are worth pausing on.
The deduction was 20% of labour; the tax was 20% of profit. Those are different bases. Confusing them is what makes people think the refund is an error in their favour.
The £8,000 of expenses saved £1,600 in tax and nothing in deductions. Expenses only work on one side of the equation. That is a good reason to keep every receipt — not to reduce the deduction, but because the deduction was already taken and the expense is what turns it into a refund.
Nobody sends you this calculation. It is assembled from your statements, your invoices and your expense records. If those are missing, the refund is what HMRC can see, which is usually less than what you are owed.
What you need to keep
- Every CIS statement. The monthly payment and deduction statement from each contractor, within 14 days of the tax month end. These are the proof of what was deducted.
- Every invoice you issued. The deduction statement must agree with the invoice, and the invoice is the record of the labour/materials split.
- Expense records with dates. Fuel, tools, PPE, insurance, subscriptions, professional fees — anything wholly and exclusively for the trade.
Keep them as you go. Reconstructing a year of statements in April from bank entries alone is the single most common reason a refund comes back smaller than expected.
Two traps
A refund is not automatic. It comes through the self assessment return, and the deduction figures have to be entered. A return that omits them shows a bill instead of a refund.
A large refund is also a warning. If the refund is unexpectedly big, check the deduction total rather than celebrating it — it is easy to double-count a statement, or to include a month that was later corrected.
The rates in this example are the ones in force when it was written. Check the current figures on GOV.UK before filing. This is general information, not tax advice.
The pack below includes a tracker for the monthly statements and an estimator that produces this calculation from your own figures, so the April number is not a surprise.
General information only, not tax or financial advice. Every guide links to the current GOV.UK page for the rules it applies.